Real Education
Thursday October 09th 2008, 2:22 pm
Filed under: College, Politics, Reading

I can’t stop re-reading this interview in the NY Times Magazine. Deborah Solomon interviews Charles Murray about his new book, “Real Education,” and it’s like some morbidly funny train wreck and I can’t not look. Some choice excerpts:

Although attending college has long been a staple of the American dream, you argue in your new book, “Real Education,” that too many kids are now heading to four-year colleges and wasting their time in pursuit of a bachelor’s degree. Yes. Let’s stop this business of the B.A., this meaningless credential. And let’s talk about having something kids can take to an employer that says what they know, not where they learned it.

You’re not the first social scientist to knock the liberal arts, but you may be the first to insist that only 20 percent of all college students have the brains and abilities to understand their assigned reading. Eighty percent are not able to deal with college-level material, traditionally understood. Someone can sit down with Paul Samuelson’s textbook and stare at the pages and know what most of the words mean. That does not mean that they walk away from it understanding economics as it is taught in the textbook.

What do you propose that 18-year-olds do instead of trying to learn the difference between macro- and microeconomics? Oh, the world of work out there!

Do you see your new book as an extension of the “The Bell Curve,” which caused an uproar in 1994 by suggesting that people are only as promising as their I.Q. scores? In many ways, it is a distillation of things I’ve been thinking since “The Bell Curve.”

Europeans have historically defined themselves through inherited traits and titles, but isn’t America a country where we are supposed to define ourselves through acts of will? I wonder if there is a single, solitary, real-live public-school teacher who agrees with the proposition that it’s all a matter of will. To me, the fact that ability varies — and varies in ways that are impossible to change — is a fact that we learn in first grade.

I believe that given the opportunity, most people could do most anything. You’re out of touch with reality in that regard. You have not hung around with kids who are well in the lower half of the ability distribution.

Have you? [He has not.]

What do you make of the fact that John McCain was ranked 894 in a class of 899 when he graduated from the U.S. Naval Academy? I like to think that the reason he ranked so low is that he was out drinking beer, as opposed to just unable to learn stuff.

What do you think of Sarah Palin? I’m in love. Truly and deeply in love.

She attended five colleges in six years. So what?

Pompous a** is all I can come up with. And yet, while I’m shaking my head in disbelief that karma alone hasn’t mowed this guy down, I also can’t stop laughing. He’s such a jacka** and is totally unapologetic about it. Whether you agree with him or not (I don’t) you have to respect the ballsiness of someone who can write a damn book explaining why the smart people should be in charge and the dumb humans should do the work. Nice.

His argument implodes for me as soon as he gets to the nonsensical/illogical portion of the interview where he’s all for McCain and Palin regardless of their questionable intelligence. He just brushes those facts aside because they clearly have no relevance. When research scientists do that, they aren’t allowed to call it science—then it’s just called “making stuff up.”

I’m confused. Is Murray saying that only the smart people should be allowed to go to college and do the super important jobs, but we don’t want any of those smarties running the country? Is running the country not an important job? Maybe he classifies the presidency as one of those below-average-intelligence-havin’ labor jobs. If that’s the case, then I’m an even bigger fan of that smart Obama guy, who, it seems, is too smart to be running the country.

Posted by Alexa Harrington

image: alec holst/school of visual arts




That’s just priceless. I don’t like manual labor. I’m glad someone was kind enough to give an average kid like me a shot at college. Oh, the world of work out there, my butt! I’ll go ahead and learn despite this jackhole’s attempt to say I’m incapable of it.

Comment by Erik 10.09.08 @ 3:55 pm

Laughter is often the only means of making some hideous aspect of reality digestible. Sadly this is one that arises from ignorance.

Let us take some task and set a large number of people to doing this in such a manner that we may measure how long it takes them to accomplish the task. We do require them to finish the task no matter how long it may take. We find that we end up with some distribution of times, which may under some circumstances be a Gaussian.

Now let us repeat the experiment and after some period of time call quit. At that point some number of people will have finished the task but the number will be less than all.

The structure of college imposes similar conditions.

Comment by Simple Country Physicist 10.11.08 @ 7:01 am

Thank you. Seriously, the philosophy of your educational institution is a major part of how and what you learn at that institution. No matter what your I.Q., it is the decision you make to attend college, the effort you put into your curriculum, and the people who nurture and support you in your academic career which influences the type of professional you become in the working world.

Comment by Nanette 10.13.08 @ 7:55 am

[...] I have had occasion recently to consider this since the matter of how long it takes to become comfortable with an idea has been thrust into my consciousness. The seed of this was Alexa Harrington’s discussion of an interview with Charles Murray. [Link] I have to admit to never having heard of this fellow before and the details of the blot revealed that I was fortunate not to have. If this man is an educator then there is scant surprise that education is in sad straits in our Yankee republic. [...]

Pingback by Mean Time to Comprehension « Simple Country Physicist 10.14.08 @ 5:36 am